Collective re-read

Comic scans and discussions, you'll find it here.

Collective re-read

Tekira
top poster
Joined: 20 Oct 2008, 14:02

11 Jan 2015, 13:07 #1

The concept
As discussed, here is the topic for the collective re-read! The idea is simple: We're going to read 1 issue each week (see the schedule below) and discuss it in this topic. The 'week' will start each Monday, to avoid confusion over time-zones I will make post when we will start to discuss the next issue. As you can see, I've not scheduled all the arcs yet, I will schedule the other arcs when we get there. This time, there are no spoiler rules! This way, we can put chapters in a greater perspective. We can make up more rules as we go if necessary, but I think this is enough for now. Also, this is a great way to check the quality of the scans. Please notify me if you encounter links that don't work, missing or unreadable pages, etc. Extra note: I use the European date notation, that is d-m-y.

Specials
I've inserted the specials according to this list (credits for Noby!). This means the specials are inserted according to Italian chronological order. The specials are semi-canon, so they can feel a bit out of place sometimes, because they usually have nothing to do with the main story. I'm also not too sure about the placement of the Christmas specials and the WITCH On Stage special, but we'll see if it makes sense when we get there. If you have suggestions to make the order better, please let me know!

*NOTE* This list doesn't contain all the scanlated works. If you are looking for mini's and other specials, please visit the Comic Scan thread.

1. Meridian
02-02-2015 - 08-02-2015: Issue #1: Halloween (updated ver.)
09-02-2015 - 15-02-2015: Issue #2: The Twelve Portals (updated ver.)
16-02-2015 - 22-02-2015: Issue #3: The Dark Dimension (last updated 1/13)
23-02-2015 - 01-03-2015: Issue #4: The Power of Fire
02-03-2015 - 08-03-2015: Issue #5: So Be It Forever
09-03-2015 - 15-03-2015: Issue #6: Illusions and Lies (re-up 22/7/13)
16-03-2015 - 22-03-2015: Issue #7: One Day You'll Meet Him
23-03-2015 - 29-03-2015: Issue #8: The Black Roses of Meridian
30-03-2015 - 05-04-2015: Issue #9: The Four Dragons (last updated 1/4/15)
06-04-2015 - 12-04-2015: Issue #10: A Bridge Between Two Worlds (re-up 1/6/14)
13-04-2015 - 19-04-2015: Issue #11: The Crown of Light (re-up 1/6/14)
20-04-2015 - 26-04-2015: Issue #12: The Challenge of Phobos (re-up 1/6/14)
27-04-2015 - 03-05-2015: SPECIAL: The Year Before

Interval
04-05-2015 - 10-05-2015: Issue #13: I Know Who You Are (re-up 1/6/14)
11-05-2015 - 17-05-2015: Issue #14: The End of a Dream (re-up 1/6/14)
18-05-2015 - 24-05-2015: Issue #15: The Courage to Choose (re-up 1/6/14)

2. Nerissa's Revenge
25-05-2015 - 31-05-2015: Issue #16: Nerissa's Seal (updated!)
01-06-2015 - 07-06-2015: Issue #17: Don't close Your Eyes (last updated 24/10/14)
08-06-2015 - 14-06-2015: Issue #18: Remnants of Summer (updated!)
15-06-2015 - 21-06-2015: Issue #19: The Other Side of the Story (last updated 2/6/14)
22-06-2015 - 28-06-2015: SPECIAL: Elyon Special
29-06-2015 - 05-07-2015: Issue #20: A Gust of Hate (re-up 2/6/14)
06-07-2015 - 12-07-2015: Issue #21: Shadows of Tomorrow (re-up 2/6/14)
13-07-2015 - 19-07-2015: Issue #22: A Broken Heart (re-up 5/6/13)
20-07-2015 - 26-05-2015: Issue #23: Goodbye
27-07-2015 - 02-08-2015: Issue #24: Trust Me (updated 22/10/13)

3. A Crisis on Both Worlds
03-08-2015 - 09-08-2015: Issue #25: Water Shadows (re-up 1/4/14)
10-08-2015 - 16-08-2015: Issue #26: Blackmail (re-up 1/8/13)
17-08-2015 - 23-08-2015: Issue #27: Divided (re-up 16/10/13)
24-08-2015 - 30-08-2015: Issue #28: So Close, Yet So Far
31-08-2015 - 06-09-2015: Issue #29: The Lesser Evil
07-09-2015 - 13-09-2015: Issue #30: The Chamber of Tempests
14-09-2015 - 20-09-2015: Issue #31: The Voice of Silence
21-09-2015 - 27-09-2015: Issue #32: Behind the Mask
28-09-2015 - 04-10-2015: SPECIAL: Caleb and Cornelia Special
05-10-2015 - 11-10-2015: Issue #33: The Greatest Gift
12-10-2015 - 18-10-2015: Issue #34: The Scent of Freedom
19-10-2015 - 25-10-2015: Issue #35: Mirrored Lives
26-10-2015 - 01-11-2015: Issue #36: Rebel Souls (last updated 24/10/14)
02-11-2015 - 08-11-2015: SPECIAL: Core of Kandrakar part 1 - part 2

4. Trial of the Oracle
16-11-2015 - 22-11-2015: Issue #37: The Dispute (last updated 2/6/14)
23-11-2015 - 29-11-2015: Issue #38: Desires of the Heart (last updated 2/6/14)
30-11-2015 - 06-12-2015: SPECIAL: BoysPlanet
07-12-2015 - 13-12-2015: Issue #39: On the Wings of Remembrance (re-up 21/12/13)
14-12-2015 - 20-12-2015: Issue #40: The Ultimate Secret (last updated 16/12/15)
21-12-2015 - 27-12-2015: Issue #41: The Whole Truth (re-up 23/12/2015)
28-12-2015 - 03-01-2016: Issue #42: Beyond all hope
04-01-2016 - 10-01-2016: Issue #43: Tricks of Light (last updated 24/10/14)
11-01-2016 - 17-01-2016: Issue #44: Never Alone, Ever Again
18-01-2016 - 24-01-2016: SPECIAL: Orube Special
25-01-2016 - 31-01-2016: Issue #45: Double Deception (last updated 1/6/14)
01-02-2016 - 07-02-2016: SPECIAL: Christmas Special 2004
08-02-2016 - 14-02-2016: Issue #46: The Power of Courage
15-02-2016 - 21-02-2016: Issue #47: The Sands of Time
22-02-2016 - 28-02-2016: Issue #48: New Horizons

5. War Against Ludmoore
29-02-2016 - 06-03-2016: Issue #49: Between Dream and Reality
07-03-2016 - 13-03-2016: Issue #50: Forever Magic
14-03-2016 - 20-03-2016: Issue #51: Out of Control
21-03-2016 - 27-03-2016: Issue #52: The Eye of the Book
28-03-2016 - 03-04-2016: Issue #53: A Whole new Song
04-04-2016 - 10-04-2016: Issue #54: One More Hug
11-04-2016 - 17-04-2016: Issue #55: The Day After
18-04-2016 - 24-04-2016: Issue #56: The Riddle
25-04-2016 - 01-05-2016: Issue #57: The Isle Of Enchantment
02-05-2016 - 08-05-2016: SPECIAL: Christmas Special 2005
09-05-2016 - 15-05-2016: Issue #58: Illusions
16-05-2016 - 22-05-2016: Issue #59: The Fire Within (last updated 10/6/14)
23-05-2016 - 29-05-2016: Issue #60: Air and Earth
30-05-2016 - 05-06-2016: Issue #61: The World in the Book
06-06-2016 - 12-06-2016: Issue #62: Between the Pages

6. Ragorlang:
13-06-2016 - 19-06-2016: Issue #63: Arrival and Departure
20-06-2016 - 26-06-2016SPECIAL: Football World Cup Special
27-06-2016 - 03-07-2016: Issue #64: The Screaming Man
04-07-2016 - 10-07-2016: Issue #65: Only a Flower
11-07-2016 - 17-07-2016: Issue #66: Reflected Memories
18-07-2016 - 24-07-2016: Issue #67: On Your Side (re-up 1/6/14)
25-07-2016 - 31-07-2016: Issue #68: The Dark Side
01-08-2016 - 07-08-2016: Issue #69: New Frontiers (re-up 1/6/14)
08-08-2016 - 14-08-2016: SPECIAL: Christmas Special 2006
15-08-2016 - 04-09-2016: Issue #70: Stop the Presses (re-up 1/6/14)
05-09-2016 - 11-09-2016: Issue #71: Glimmers of Fear (re-up 1/6/14)
12-09-2016 - 18-09-2016: Issue #72: The Green Ray (re-up 1/6/14)
19-09-2016 - 25-09-2016: SPECIAL: Caleb and Elyon
26-09-2016 - 02-10-2016: Issue #73: The Dark Summons
03-10-2016 - 09-10-2016: Issue #74: Whisked Away

SPECIAL: WITCH On Stage:
10-10-2016 - 16-10-2016: Issue #1: A Special School
10-10-2016 - 16-10-2016: Issue #2: The Idea
17-10-2016 - 23-10-2016: Issue #3: The Script
17-10-2016 - 23-10-2016: Issue #4: The Audition
24-10-2016 - 30-10-2016: Issue #5: The Rehearsals
24-10-2016 - 30-10-2016: Issue #6: The Band
31-10-2016 - 06-11-2016: Issue #7: The Costumes
31-10-2016 - 06-11-2016: Issue #8: The Scenography
07-11-2016 - 13-11-2016: Issue #9: The Choreography
07-11-2016 - 13-11-2016: Issue #10: The Blog
14-11-2016 - 20-11-2016: Issue #11: Advertising The Show
14-11-2016 - 20-11-2016: Issue #12: MAGIC the Musical

7. New Power:
21-11-2016 - 27-22-2016:Issue #75: As You Were, You Are Now
28-11-2016 - 04-12-2016: Issue #76: Earth (url update 1/6/14)
05-12-2016 - 11-12-2016: Issue #77: Of all the Stars (url update 1/6/14)
12-12-2016 - 18-12-2016: Issue #78: Fire (url update 1/6/14)
19-12-2016 - 25-12-2016: Issue #79: Water (url update 1/6/14)
26-12-2016 - 01-01-2017: Issue #80: Emotions (url update 1/6/14)
02-01-2017 - 08-01-2017: SPECIAL: Halloween 2008: Night of Magic
09-01-2017 - 15-01-2017: Issue #81: Air (url update 1/6/14)
16-01-2017 - 22-01-2017: Issue #82: Energy (url update 1/6/14)
23-01-2017 - 29-01-2017: Issue #83: Return to Kandrakar (url update 1/6/14)
30-01-2017 - 05-02-2017: Issue #84: Unique Movements (url update 1/6/14)
06-02-2017 - 12-02-2017: issue #85: I am You (url update 1/6/14)
13-02-2017 - 19-02-2017: Issue #86: In the Heart (url update 1/6/14)

8. Teach 2b Witch:
20-02-2017 - 26-02-2017: Issue #87: A Cold Magic (url update 1/6/14)
26-02-2017 - 05-03-2017: Issue #88: Which One of You? (url update 1/6/14)
06-03-2017 - 12-03-2017: Issue #89: The Key To Summer (url update 1/6/14)
13-03-2017 - 19-03-2017: SPECIAL: Olympic Special 2008
20-03-2017 - 26-03-2017: Issue #90: A Beating Heart (url update 1/6/14)
27-03-2017 - 02-04-2017: Issue #91: So Much More (url update 1/6/14)
03-04-2017 - 09-04-2017: Issue #92: No Longer Alone (url update 1/6/14)
10-04-2017 - 16-04-2017: Issue #93: From a Place Far Away (url update 1/6/14)
17-04-2017 - 23-04-2017: Issue #94: The Settlement (url update 1/6/14)
24-04-2017 - 30-04-2017: Issue #95: Endless Tears
01-05-2017 - 07-05-2017: Issue #96: Here Inside The Heart
08-05-2017 - 14-05-2017: Issue #97: The Magic Of The World
15-05-2017 - 21-05-2017: Issue #98: Wonderful, After All
22-05-2017 - 28-05-2017: Issue #99: A Dive Into The Air

9. 100% WITCH:
29-05-2017 - 04-06-2017: Issue #100: 100% Witch
05-06-2017 - 11-06-2017: Issue #101: A Rising Star
12-06-2017 - 18-06-2017Issue #102: The First Day
19-06-2017 - 25-06-2017: Issue #103: The One You're Not
26-06-2017 - 02-07-2017: Issue #104: Another World
03-07-2017 - 09-07-2017: Issue #105: A Dream Letter
10-07-2017 - 16-07-2017: Issue #106: Zodiac
17-07-2017 - 23-07-2017: Issue #107: It Was Fated
21-08-2017 - 27-08-2017: Issue #108: A Father's Heart
28-08-2017 - 03-09-2017: Issue #109: Green Truth
04-09-2017 - 10-09-2017: Issue #110: Magical Moms
11-09-2017 - 17-09-2017: Issue #111: Teamwork
18-09-2017 - 24-09-2017: Issue #112: Early Days
25-09-2017 - 01-10-2017: Issue #113: The Long Kiss
02-10-2017 - 08-10-2017: Issue #114: Back To School
09-10-2017 - 15-10-2017: Issue #115: A Special Journey
16-10-2017 - 22-10-2017: Issue #116: The Right Distance
23-10-2017 - 29-10-2017: Issue #117: The Most Beautiful Occasion

10. Ladies Vs. W.I.T.C.H.
04-12-2017 - 10-12-2017: Issue #118: All In A Day
11-12-2017 - 17-12-2017: Issue #119: Music In The Air
18-12-2017 - 24-12-2017:Issue #120: Lady Giga
25-12-2017 - 31-12-2017: Issue #121: Ten Years Later
01-01-2018 - 07-01-2018: Issue #122: Mathematically Possible
08-01-2018 - 14-01-2018: Issue #123: Lady Crash
15-01-2018 - 21-01-2018: Issue #124: A Friendly Creature
22-01-2018 - 28-01-2018: Issue #125: The Other Half
29-01-2018 - 04-02-2018: Issue #126: Lady Kimikal
05-02-2018 - 11-02-2018: Issue #127: Embrace Me
12-02-2018- 18-02-2018: Issue #128: Just One Word
19-02-2018 - 26-02-2018: Issue #129: Far From The Heart

11. Magical Sovereigns
Issue #130: A New Friend
Issue #131: The Magic Of Emotions
Issue #132: Always Together
Issue #133: Little Magic
Issue #134: Tomorrow
Issue #135: Similar At Heart
Issue #136: Over The Net
Issue #137: Tell Me
Issue #138: A Different World
Issue #139: Witch!
Facebook * Hot Cute Girly Geek * 3DS: 107507154451
Reply

MoonCloud217
top poster
Joined: 22 Dec 2006, 14:33

11 Jan 2015, 14:37 #2

great :) i hope i will have time to join.

do you think we will have discussions for every issue in this very same thread? i was thinking that maybe we could re-use the old arc threads to make discussions more focused. for example: someone might miss a week and want to discuss last week's re-read, without interfering too much in the newest discussions.

that is up to you to decide though :D if you rather keep all discussions in the same thread, we could unpin the old arc threads or maybe even lock them, at least until the re-read is over ( i wonder how many years it will take ^_^ ) .
"the queen of WITCH since forever" --- Omar @ facebook.com/MoonCloud217
Reply

Mister_Mister
Comic Reader
Joined: 11 Jan 2015, 15:09

11 Jan 2015, 15:30 #3

This sounds like fun. I just might join in on the disscusion. I found out about this tranlation project just last week after searching the web for information on W.I.T.C.H.
It was one of the comics I never got around to read, but it always had my curiosity. So finally being able to read and discuss the comic from the beginning seems like something I could get caught up in, at least slightly.

We'll see.
Reply

neraida
feline forum warrior
Joined: 27 Jan 2010, 15:37

11 Jan 2015, 17:07 #4

Though I think that one issue per week could be a bit too much concering my busy schedule, I will definetely participate to the collective re-read for every issue. I love this idea. We can find new perspectives to the story.
Reply

Tekira
top poster
Joined: 20 Oct 2008, 14:02

12 Jan 2015, 06:57 #5

MoonCloud217 @ 11 January 2015 16:37 wrote: great :) i hope i will have time to join.

do you think we will have discussions for every issue in this very same thread? i was thinking that maybe we could re-use the old arc threads to make discussions more focused. for example: someone might miss a week and want to discuss last week's re-read, without interfering too much in the newest discussions.

that is up to you to decide though :D if you rather keep all discussions in the same thread, we could unpin the old arc threads or maybe even lock them, at least until the re-read is over ( i wonder how many years it will take ^_^ ) .
I actually wanted to use only this thread. I considered your option too, but I thought that could get e bit confusing (especially for new members), and since we're also going to insert the specials. Of course members can still use the arc threads to discuss arcs we already read ;)
Facebook * Hot Cute Girly Geek * 3DS: 107507154451
Reply

ivan_georgiev
Comic Fan
Joined: 26 Jul 2011, 09:34

12 Jan 2015, 09:25 #6

Awesome idea to keep W.I.T.C.H. and the forum alive! :) Long live W.I.T.C.H.! :will: :irma: :taranee: :cornelia: :haylin:
Reply

chevalierkraken
Comic Fan
Joined: 08 Jan 2015, 04:24

12 Jan 2015, 19:51 #7

I'll said chrismas special 2004 and 2005 are set in same time, as one is a new year special and not christmas (and the last version of the 2004 special, published in france in 2006 with more art mention jensen academy where tara just entered) and season 4 don't seem to be place in winter.

I'll also place WITCH on stage all along season 7.

Same thing, I don't see christmas special 2006 taking place during season but 8 (as cornelia date with Peter)

And I want to point there is a last chrismas special(not scanned) that I place during season 7 where Eric came back to heatherfield to see Hay lin
Reply

MoonCloud217
top poster
Joined: 22 Dec 2006, 14:33

12 Jan 2015, 20:20 #8

you keep saying that one of the scanned xmas specials take place during new year, but can you specifically say which one? personally, i don't understand what you're talking about, all three scanned xmas specials make it clear that it is christmas time, not new years time. are you saying there is a mistranslation? it would be logical either, since one story is about the evil santa, the other one is about gifts and the third one is a christmas show (there are a xmas tree and xmas decorations). there is nothing mentioned about a new year celbration anywhere.

interesting though if what you say about a fourth xmas special is true. do you have any proof?
"the queen of WITCH since forever" --- Omar @ facebook.com/MoonCloud217
Reply

Tekira
top poster
Joined: 20 Oct 2008, 14:02

12 Jan 2015, 21:23 #9

season 4 don't seem to be place in winter.
That's because the Christmas special are released during real-time Christmas, unlike the canon story that has nothing to do with real time seasons. So it's perfectly possible that it's summer in the canon story while it's winter in the Christmas special that was released during that time. That's what I meant when I said that the specials may feel out of place a little bit.
I'll also place WITCH on stage all along season 7.
I thought about that too, since WITCH on stage was published alongside arc 7, but I decided to do it this way for continuity-sake.
Facebook * Hot Cute Girly Geek * 3DS: 107507154451
Reply

MoonCloud217
top poster
Joined: 22 Dec 2006, 14:33

12 Jan 2015, 21:40 #10

Tekira @ 12 January 2015 22:23 wrote: the canon story (..) has nothing to do with real time seasons.
i dont remember much of the detailed art from the older comics, but i kinda disagree with this.

for example, at least in newer issues, you never see the girls hanging out on the beach in an issue released in january in Italy. and the weather tend to be more gloomy and cold-looking (even if there's not always snow) when it's not summer during an Italian release.

but i dont know how much they keep track of the seasons when the girls are in other parts of the universe :)
"the queen of WITCH since forever" --- Omar @ facebook.com/MoonCloud217
Reply

chevalierkraken
Comic Fan
Joined: 08 Jan 2015, 04:24

13 Jan 2015, 00:04 #11

MoonCloud217 @ 12 January 2015 21:20 wrote: you keep saying that one of the scanned xmas specials take place during new year, but can you specifically say which one? personally, i don't understand what you're talking about, all three scanned xmas specials make it clear that it is christmas time, not new years time. are you saying there is a mistranslation? it would be logical either, since one story is about the evil santa, the other one is about gifts and the third one is a christmas show (there are a xmas tree and xmas decorations). there is nothing mentioned about a new year celbration anywhere.

interesting though if what you say about a fourth xmas special is true. do you have any proof?
You are right, I have just reread the special and yes, it's take place at christmas, I was fooled by the content of the show

the show seem to be a new year show, Hay lin even say about it "Our performance bring a wonderful year to an end" the character also talk about their resolution for new year.
the show even include decoration for every month of the year

And what made this special even look like more a new year special is also the fact the whole comics was a calendar for the new year.

And yes I have proof for the forth chrismas special, I have this one at home. I could try to scan it (and the page you didn't includ in the 2004 new years special) the story in into the "Witch mag hors série n°16" with some issues of Witch on stage (who never be fully published in france)

you can buy it here

http://www.priceminister.com/offer?acti ... =139314132

so I think 2004 special (with the Show) take place during season 5, the one with the girls making present take place during season 3 and the last one don't seem to fit anywhere (The girl have their old outfit, but Cornelia dating with Peter, so except if Peter have succeded to obtain a date with Corny during season 1, it fit nowhere even in at his date of release because during season 6 Cornelia was not with peter)
Reply

MoonCloud217
top poster
Joined: 22 Dec 2006, 14:33

13 Jan 2015, 06:52 #12

alright, i wonder how come it's not in Noby's list though? I had a feeling she knew of all specials.

edit: I asked VegaStar (the italian girl who helps me translate) and she says:

"Are you sure it's not the special Christmas issue you already translated?
The one in which Eric asks for help to get a present for Hay Lin and the
girls make a mess trying to help? I really cannot find anything about that."


if you could make scans or just take a photo or two, that would be great though. i'd love to buy it first when i have it confirmed that i dont already own it. plus, french issues are known to have missing pages.
"the queen of WITCH since forever" --- Omar @ facebook.com/MoonCloud217
Reply

Tekira
top poster
Joined: 20 Oct 2008, 14:02

13 Jan 2015, 13:04 #13

MoonCloud217 @ 12 January 2015 23:40 wrote: for example, at least in newer issues, you never see the girls hanging out on the beach in an issue released in january in Italy. and the weather tend to be more gloomy and cold-looking (even if there's not always snow) when it's not summer during an Italian release.
ah, I never realized :ph43r:
Facebook * Hot Cute Girly Geek * 3DS: 107507154451
Reply

chevalierkraken
Comic Fan
Joined: 08 Jan 2015, 04:24

13 Jan 2015, 15:16 #14

MoonCloud217 @ 13 January 2015 07:52 wrote:

"
The one in which Eric asks for help to get a present for Hay Lin and the
girls make a mess trying to help?

It's this one, but it's not already translated... I can't find it anywhere here nor into Noby list
Reply

MoonCloud217
top poster
Joined: 22 Dec 2006, 14:33

13 Jan 2015, 15:54 #15

Found it :) http://witchoholic.xbizhost.com/perfectgift.html

but i think these mini comics are too short and too many to enter into the timeline,
or what do you think Tekira?
"the queen of WITCH since forever" --- Omar @ facebook.com/MoonCloud217
Reply

sinekashii
Comic Reader
Joined: 13 Jan 2015, 09:23

15 Jan 2015, 12:48 #16

Ah that's an great idea to reread the issues ^^

I was wondering if any of you seen the illustrator of witch issue #1 draw again? When I was collecting I don't think I saw her, I think if I remember correctly I read it was the creator who drew the first issue, so Elisabetta?

Anyways I thought her(or maybe his) colouring and drawing style is very nice, especially the way she drew Will's hair was interesting.
Reply

Tekira
top poster
Joined: 20 Oct 2008, 14:02

15 Jan 2015, 21:23 #17

MoonCloud217 @ 13 January 2015 17:54 wrote: Found it :) http://witchoholic.xbizhost.com/perfectgift.html

but i think these mini comics are too short and too many to enter into the timeline,
or what do you think Tekira?
My thoughts exactly ;)
Facebook * Hot Cute Girly Geek * 3DS: 107507154451
Reply

pokemastercube
online gardener
Joined: 02 Feb 2007, 22:24

15 Jan 2015, 23:23 #18

maybe just have them linked for looking at if someone has some extra time
crazy and proud
Reply

Tekira
top poster
Joined: 20 Oct 2008, 14:02

16 Jan 2015, 09:53 #19

Nah, they can find them in the comic scan thread right? But I will make a note that this list doesn't contain all the scanlated works.
Facebook * Hot Cute Girly Geek * 3DS: 107507154451
Reply

neraida
feline forum warrior
Joined: 27 Jan 2010, 15:37

16 Jan 2015, 12:46 #20

Tekira, do you think that it would be nice if the start of the conversation for each issue started with a post containing just the cover of the current issue? So that if someone scrolls (when this thread will have many posts), he can distinguish the posts concering a specific issue by spoting the photos of two covers. Ok I think I described what I wanted to say like a ten year old but currently, it seems like I have forgotten how to speak in english :P
Reply

Tekira
top poster
Joined: 20 Oct 2008, 14:02

16 Jan 2015, 15:23 #21

Great idea! I'll do that!
Facebook * Hot Cute Girly Geek * 3DS: 107507154451
Reply

Alatar Elentari
Comic Reader
Joined: 23 Sep 2014, 08:23

17 Jan 2015, 11:53 #22

Re-read? :lol: I read them so many time that some chapters I know them very good. I will not be in this project.
Sorry. But if I start to read again I'm afraid that will get tired and I not like anymore.
Reply

RWB
Comic Reader
Joined: 03 Feb 2008, 23:52

27 Jan 2015, 22:06 #23

I'm all in on this.

Still, I will warn everyone beforehand that I think the latter half of the first arc is a terrible mess and that #7 might actually be the worst comic in the series as a whole(not in and of itself, but because it breaks the plot/symbolism/characters in half and does a terrible job of salvaging it.), worse than any of the "Post-Arc" comics, even.

Also, expect quite a bit of complaints about Deus Ex Machina at the end of most arcs(not all, I don't think). I usually don't like to bring the term up because people use it for everything... but this series has a legitimate problem with DeM.
Reply

Tekira
top poster
Joined: 20 Oct 2008, 14:02

28 Jan 2015, 12:16 #24

Critical analyses are welcome ;)
Facebook * Hot Cute Girly Geek * 3DS: 107507154451
Reply

Tekira
top poster
Joined: 20 Oct 2008, 14:02

02 Feb 2015, 10:05 #25

Hurray! The Collective re-read has officially started! As of right now, I invite you to read and discuss Issue #1: Halloween

Facebook * Hot Cute Girly Geek * 3DS: 107507154451
Reply