Jaguar (Panthera onca) interactions with Giant Otters (Pteronura brasiliensis)

Joined: February 11th, 2012, 7:29 am

April 27th, 2018, 5:18 am #1

[size=150][size=150][b]Giant Otters in the Water? Jaguars Think Twice.[/b][/size][/size]

Fernando Tortato
Ailton Lara
Rafael Hoogesteijn

April 3, 2018

Editor's Note: This is Part One in a series about the surprising interactions between jaguars and giant otters. Read Part Two here. Rafael Hoogesteijn is Conflict Program Director for Panthera's Jaguar Program in the Brazilian Pantanal. Fernando Tortato is a Panthera Research Associate there. Ailton Lara is Director of wildlife tour company Pantanal Nature.

The Brazilian Pantanal, one of the largest floodplains in the world, has the highest population densities of jaguars in the species’ entire range. In the Porto Jofre region in the north, Panthera Brasil owns the 10,000-hectare Jofre Velho Ranch, dedicated to wildlife conservation and research, jaguar conflict resolution, and community education.

Here, we have the incredible opportunity to observe this great feline and discover behaviors that are often undetectable through conventional research methods like camera-trapping and radio collars. It’s easy to see jaguars during the dry season resting or prowling on the riverbanks. Jaguar social behavior is also frequently documented: females caring for cubs, couples mating, and even adult males sharing a sunny beach on the banks of the Cuiabá and São Lourenço rivers.

[img width=700 height=409][/img]
[i]A jaguar we often watch hunting and resting on river banks[/i] [size=50][size=50]© RAFAEL HOOGESTEIJN/PANTHERA[/size][/size]

But observing them hunting or interacting with other jaguars or other species can be difficult. Some of the most surprising encounters are between jaguars and giant otters ([i]Pteronura brasiliensis[/i]).

Giant otters are carnivorous, formidable, and extremely agile aquatic predators (to the extent that they are called the “aquatic jaguar” by some local indigenous tribes) and are always in social groups taking care of their territory and one other. The most suitable period for their breeding is when the waters of the Pantanal are low—because they can easily find fish and build predator-proof lairs out of exposed riverbanks, gullies, and roots.

The water weasels demarcate their territories by defecating and urinating at the entrance of their dens, compressing mud with feet and tails, and creating layers of latrines. When the water level is low, the otters need to adjust or change their den location—lest they and their young become vulnerable to attacks by jaguars.

[img width=700 height=413][/img]
[i]This male giant otter confronted two jaguars with head movements, calls, and occasional jumps.[/i] [size=50][size=50]© RAFAEL HOOGESTEIJN/PANTHERA[/size][/size]

Even the jaguar—a versatile feline that climbs trees, moves imperceptibly through forests, and does not see the water as a barrier—thinks twice before entering a river when otters are nearby. Drinking water near them can become an arduous, worrying, and challenging task.

In October, at the end of the dry season, the waters of rivers and lagoons are low, with trunks and dead tree branches more exposed on the banks of rivers and corixos (seasonal water-streams). This past fall, we had the privilege of watching two jaguar sisters (both with surprisingly light coats) being challenged by a dominant male giant otter that fiercely defended its aquatic territory.

The jaguars, who were initially resting on a dry trunk on the banks of Corixo Negro in the heat of the afternoon, decided to go down the trunk to the water line to quench their thirst. But even before drinking the water, they were confronted by the audacious otter, who, with quick dives between the submerged branches, always surprised the sisters.

With the characteristic vocalizations of giant otters, this male made clear who dominated the submerged realm of the Pantanal. The sisters were left with expressions that seemed a mixture of surprise and curiosity.

The jaguar sisters—named Medrosa and Jaju by local guides—are between 2 to 3 years old. Young jaguars primarily hunt prey through lessons learned from their mother. The sisters’ mother, Patricia, is an excellent caiman hunter, but we have no record of her standing against giant otters. So the young females may have feared the otter because of never seeing their mother face its kind before.

The otter, realizing the two sisters were scared, was emboldened to protect one of his favorite tree trunks in this fish-productive water-stream. His group had their den nearby and used this trunk daily as a basking place and a nice feeding station.

[img width=700 height=467][/img]
[i]The jaguar sisters react to the otter's confrontation.[/i] [size=50][size=50]© RAFAEL HOOGESTEIJN/PANTHERA[/size][/size]

So, after about 15 minutes of action, the jaguars retreated, patrolling the banks of the corixo in search of an inattentive caiman or capybara. We were among about 20 privileged witnesses of this agonistic interaction of these incredible carnivores, and we all smiled and celebrated the incredible experience we saw, photographed, and filmed. In this case, it was a happy ending for both parties.

In a semi-aquatic world like the Pantanal, encounters between jaguars and giant otters are inevitable. But the otter is not part of the jaguar’s natural staple diet, which consists mostly of capybaras and caimans.

A 2016 article described three agonistic encounters between giant otters and jaguars in the Pantanal. The result of these encounters was similar to the ones we have observed—the jaguars were repelled twice by a group of giant otters and once by a solitary otter.

[img width=700 height=467][/img]
[i]One of the jaguars investigates the scene[/i].[size=50][size=50]© RAFAEL HOOGESTEIJN/PANTHERA[/size][/size]

But otters do not always rule the situation. Ramalheira and collaborators registered the first predation of giant otters by jaguars. The event took place on the Balbina Hydroelectric Dam in the Brazilian Amazon, where a solitary otter, which had been monitored by a radio-collar, was found killed by a jaguar in a burrow below a log on the banks of the lake. Out of the water, the otter loses all its agility and becomes vulnerable prey for an attentive jaguar.

This rare occurrence was only documented because of the otter’s collar. Giant otters can walk a few meters into the ravines of their dens, making it virtually impossible to observe what is happening inside.

[img width=700 height=418][/img]
[i]One female playfully bites her sister to make her go backwards so they can leave the area, finishing the confrontation.[/i] [size=50][size=50]© RAFAEL HOOGESTEIJN/PANTHERA[/size][/size]

From the comfort of our boats, researchers like us are lucky to observe encounters like these between two worlds, terrestrial and aquatic, where jaguars and otters recognize their strengths and limitations. And so, we enjoy the life of these incredible Pantanal predators, who are both vital for the maintenance of the ecosystems in which they survive.


[hr] [size=150][size=150][b]Otters Gang Up on a Jaguar[/b][/size][/size]

Ailton Lara
Director, Pantanal Nature

April 16, 2018

I was ferrying some tourists along the São Lourenço River near Panthera’s Brazilian research station when we spotted a surprising aquatic skirmish.

Ague, a female jaguar around 3 years old, had chosen the wrong spot to sit and take in the river view. The particular log she perched upon also happen to be a favorite for the area’s giant river otters to dine on fish, and the proximity to their den full of pups was too close for comfort.

So the otters made some noise, refusing to stand for the intrusion.

Eliminating the threat this big cat posed to the giant otters, also known as “ariranhas,” was a task accomplished with teamwork. First alerting the alpha male of the situation with loud vocalizations, the frenzied group of otters proceeded to storm up to Ague from the water, screaming and dashing in front of her. It was clear that their intimidation tactics were working, as continuous, flicking tail movements indicated the jaguar’s fear response.

Meanwhile, the dominant male otter, who had been separated from the group scouting new den sites, came onto the scene after hearing alarm calls. Ague, realizing that the fierce male was coming to the aid of his group, pulled an impressive maneuver that only cats are known to perform--turning around almost in a somersault--to flee the otter mob.

Following the lead of their alpha male, the other otters surged forward in unison with a flurry of derisive and intimidating sounds.

Not to be deterred from relaxing by the river, the same jaguar was observed the next day calmly lying in the shade of a tree. However, days later, it appeared the giant otters were ready to relocate, as the group was spotted 2.10 km away along the riverbed readying a previously-used nest. After the debacle with Ague in their territory, the dominant male moved the group to this quieter, more favorable den site, whose entrance was closer to the water.

Two months later, however, with rising water levels affecting the distance between the river and the den entrance, the same family of otters made another change in real estate, returning to the initial burrow.


[hr] [b]Video of the above two interactions:[/b]

[hr] [b]Video of Otters mobbing a Jaguar leaving it with a paw wound[/b]

[hr] The only recorded/known killing of an Otter by a Jaguar:

[b]Journal Reference:[/b]
dos Santos Ramalheira, Claudiane & Freitas Bozzetti, Bruno & Duarte da Cruz, Andrews & Palmeirim, Ana & Cabral, Marcia & Rosas, Fernando. (2015). [size=150][b]First record of jaguar predation on giant otter ([i]Pteronura brasiliensis[/i]).[/b][/size] Animal Biology. 65. 81-86. 10.1163/15707563-00002461.

[i]Top of the food chain predators are often not predated upon. However, even though the giant otter (Pteronura brasiliensis) is in that category, the literature mentions many species as potential predators, including the jaguar (Panthera onca). Notwithstanding up until now there has been no registered confirmation of jaguar predation on giant otters. A predation of a jaguar on an adult female giant otter was recorded for the first time during our radio-telemetry study on giant otters in Balbina hydroelectric reservoir in Central Brazilian Amazon. The female had had a transmitter implanted on February 2012 and was killed by a jaguar ninety-four days after the surgery. This giant otter was a solitary specimen, which was captured by a jaguar while asleep in a shelter under a fallen tree trunk on the banks of one of the reservoir’s islands. The solitary pattern found in such individuals combined with the frequent use of shelters, allows predators to access them more easily and may have contributed to the predation observed in this study. [/i]