Middlesex seek ECB hearing..

Joined: 14 Apr 2009, 14:26

03 Oct 2017, 20:13 #51

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ion-furore

Can't be having Somerset relegated retrospectively from here, surely. The whole dynamic of the last match could have been completely different. Any appeal should have been lodged and dealt with prior to the final game.
As said earlier they do have a good case however think we all know if it had been for example Durham the fixtures would have been out by now.
Reply
Like

Joined: 08 Dec 2013, 13:18

03 Oct 2017, 21:23 #52

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ion-furore

Can't be having Somerset relegated retrospectively from here, surely. The whole dynamic of the last match could have been completely different. Any appeal should have been lodged and dealt with prior to the final game.
A bit of revisionism here I feel- last year the ECB denied the County Championship a showcase and a great finish by preventing Root and Bairstow from playing? Funny that, as the vast majority of coverage I saw agreed that a great finish was exactly what the Championship did get: going into the last session of the last match of the season any of three counties were potential winners, with an ex-England player playing the innings of his life and the contest eventually being decided by a hat-trick, all live on Sky- what can get better than that?? (Other than the final outcome from my perspective of course...)

The real disgrace last year was the relegation of Durham, decided not by matters on the pitch but in a committee room after the season had finished, and on financial rather than sporting grounds. I don't see the Middlsex situation as similar; yes, they were unfortunate that the crossbow incident denied them the chance of catching up on the overs, but so are every side that loses play to rain and thus loses the potential for points throughout the season. It was their fault that they had fallen behind in the first place, and even after the points deduction they had three matches to right the supposed wrong and weren't good enough to do so, falling to two consecutive defeats to end the season. They deservedly got relegated based entirely on matters on the pitch, and if the ECB once again change the relegation spots after the season has finished that action will be the one that further puts the Championship into disrepute.
Reply
Like

Joined: 02 Apr 2014, 17:47

03 Oct 2017, 22:16 #53

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ion-furore

Can't be having Somerset relegated retrospectively from here, surely. The whole dynamic of the last match could have been completely different. Any appeal should have been lodged and dealt with prior to the final game.
If, as suggested above, the reversion to a 9 team division 1 in 2018 will be for one season only, there are two alternatives for reducing the number down to 8 again in 2019.

1. Relegate three teams from division 1. This would be unjust to the six established division 1 teams and Worcester and Notts as the two promoted counties. Other things being equal, in 2018 they would have a 33% chance of finishing 7th, 8th or 9th out of nine rather than a 25% chance of finishing 7th or 8th out of eight.

2. Promote only one team from division 2. This would be unjust to all nine division 2 counties. Other things being equal, in 2018 they would have only an 11% chance of finishing first and gaining promotion from the 9 team division compared with a 20% chance of finishing first or second in a 10 team division.

So it is incorrect to suggest that the "solution" of not relegating either Middlesex or Somerset would be fair to all concerned.
Reply
Like

Joined: 04 Jun 2015, 18:32

04 Oct 2017, 07:44 #54

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ion-furore

Can't be having Somerset relegated retrospectively from here, surely. The whole dynamic of the last match could have been completely different. Any appeal should have been lodged and dealt with prior to the final game.
So if they go back to nine teams in div 1 no doubt the extra games will have to be played in February and October....

Sorry Alex. I don't think people are giving you flak but just arguing the case from the other side of the fence. Perhaps we can go back to our game when four leg byes were not given denying us a batting point that may have been crucial and then Somerset may feel a dodgy lbw can be overturned by belatedly using DRS.
Reply
Like

Joined: 20 Oct 2013, 20:03

04 Oct 2017, 08:23 #55

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ion-furore

Can't be having Somerset relegated retrospectively from here, surely. The whole dynamic of the last match could have been completely different. Any appeal should have been lodged and dealt with prior to the final game.
If it comes to a legal issue I suspect the key is whether a 'bolt from the blue' (not often one can use that expression literally) can be regarded as the equivalent of a rain storm in its impact on a match. That will be for lawyers to determine.

My own sympathies certainly do not lie with Middlesex. They had got behind a required over rate which demands little in the way of haste to begin with, indeed it is laughable by the standards of 20 years ago. Their defence is that they were likely to take steps to rectify that. Presumably this means selecting bowlers not for any purpose related to the match situation, the pitch, or any tactical considerations. I hate watching this sort of thing. If it has an element of risk from factors unknown attached to it, good.
Reply
Like

Joined: 04 Jun 2015, 18:32

09 Oct 2017, 21:39 #56

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ion-furore

Can't be having Somerset relegated retrospectively from here, surely. The whole dynamic of the last match could have been completely different. Any appeal should have been lodged and dealt with prior to the final game.
It's gone quiet on this one.

Perhaps they should have a play off match to decide who goes down. With pink balls, in a tent played in November. Middlesex will be allowed all their Englsnd players. Somerset can't have the Overtons as with England and they look the same so not sure which one would play so both banned.
Reply
Like

Joined: 08 Dec 2013, 13:18

10 Oct 2017, 17:37 #57

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ion-furore

Can't be having Somerset relegated retrospectively from here, surely. The whole dynamic of the last match could have been completely different. Any appeal should have been lodged and dealt with prior to the final game.
Jack Leach also unavailable- they've decided they don't like his action again.
Reply
Like

Joined: 20 Aug 2013, 11:26

10 Oct 2017, 18:15 #58

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ion-furore

Can't be having Somerset relegated retrospectively from here, surely. The whole dynamic of the last match could have been completely different. Any appeal should have been lodged and dealt with prior to the final game.
It`s time they sorted out the Middlesex business, made a decision and got on with doing next years fixtures or they will be even later than the normal late November this year.
Reply
Like

Joined: 04 Apr 2017, 10:59

11 Oct 2017, 10:20 #59

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ion-furore

Can't be having Somerset relegated retrospectively from here, surely. The whole dynamic of the last match could have been completely different. Any appeal should have been lodged and dealt with prior to the final game.
Stu - my impression is that there has been a bit of misunderstanding on cricket messageboards about this - the Middlesex business is sorted out.

The reason the ECB have said nothing is because, at least from their point of view, there is nothing to say. Of course I could be wrong, but I don't think the ECB are now going to issue a statement saying "Nothing happened".

Middlesex CEO Richard Goatley said back in September that: "We have been advised that since the ECB has chosen to follow the published playing conditions in this instance, there is no scope for any further appeal."

A rumour then circulated that Middlesex could be reprieved with a 9-9 division split reinstated. But this was just based on an opinion, expressed by Dave Fulton, I believe.

A poster on the Middlesex message board wrote: "The draft fixture list for 2018 does now exist." The person who wrote that said they had attended the Middölesex end-of-season do, so I assume they gathered the fact there.



Reply
Like

Joined: 07 Oct 2014, 11:05

11 Oct 2017, 10:37 #60

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ion-furore

Can't be having Somerset relegated retrospectively from here, surely. The whole dynamic of the last match could have been completely different. Any appeal should have been lodged and dealt with prior to the final game.
"The English domestic season may have ended almost two weeks ago, but it still remains unclear whether Middlesex or Somerset will be relegated from Division One of the County Championship after the ECB confirmed they are considering Middlesex's appeal against an overrate penalty."

http://www.espncricinfo.com/story/_/id/ ... ,-says-ecb
Reply
Like