Stick welding electrical question.......

Discussion about anything related to Mig, Stick, and/or Tig welding.

Stick welding electrical question.......

Markopolo
Advanced Member
Markopolo
Advanced Member
Joined: 30 Jul 2005, 13:47

27 Nov 2005, 01:22 #1

OK, I've got a question (so what ELSE is new)......

I've got a Miller Thunderbolt XL (ac/dc) in my shop, and also a Lincoln Precision-Tig 185......Both of which can be used for stick welding.

I've found that one of these machines (which will not be named at this point) SEEMS to give me a noticeably nicer arc when stick welding.

Being the "common-sense" kind of guy that I am, I'm aware that this phenomenon may very well just be a "figment of my imagination".

QUESTION: Is there anyone out there that knows enough about the electrical configuration of these two machines that would explain if one or the other machine is more well suited to stick welding ?

THANKS !.....Marko.
"Any day above ground is a good one !"
Reply
Like

Franz©
Advanced Member
Franz©
Advanced Member
Joined: 23 Jul 2005, 17:54

27 Nov 2005, 01:53 #2

Well Nephew, you ain't seein things, and you are becoming a better stick weldor.

I went from a Lincoln coffy grinder rotary to my P&H when the Lincoln blew it's stator on the drive end, and wondered if I knew diddle about stick, or had myself a stroke when I tried to stick with the P&H. The P&H has a sweet arc quality on TIG, and ain't for shyt on stick.
Now, the funny part, I came into a second P&H a number of years later, and the guy using it was doing stick with the machine. Same flippin model machine, and it had a decent arc on stick.
Different machines, even from different manufacturers will deliver a different arc. It's just part of the game.
Deposed Dictator, still in posession of the treasury
This message was composed entirely from recycled words and phrases using only renewable, caffeinated energy sources. No trees or whales died in the process.
Reply
Like

clintonwelding1
Advanced Member
clintonwelding1
Advanced Member
Joined: 20 Dec 2005, 02:47

21 Dec 2005, 00:29 #3

i found that the miller ran a little nicer than teh lincoln and i would say taht this is because the miller is mainley ment for stick where as teh lincoln is manily used as a tig welder
arcone inverter W/ scratch start tig setup
don't consider it a tool but B&D 4 1/2 grinder
victor o/a torch
Miller XLIX STARS AND STRIPES
TRUE TO BLUE
MILLERMATIC 135 \
task force chopsaw
Craftsman 263 piece mechanics tool set
Reply
Like

7018
Advanced Member
7018
Advanced Member
Joined: 06 Jan 2005, 12:24

21 Dec 2005, 07:50 #4

Marko I think your talking about the linclon having the better arc.I have found that in the smaller machines that Linclon out preforms miller hands down.So please let me know if I'm right. :P
I'm out working!!Not really just Kidding.....
Reply
Like

arcdawg
Advanced Member
arcdawg
Advanced Member
Joined: 09 Jul 2005, 15:19

21 Dec 2005, 15:51 #5

I would rather have a buzz box for stick and then the tig machine......For me it just seems like you would get the *innards* of the tig machine too dirty from all the slag and such....and at the prices that they get for a Tig machine....well.....

how bout stepping up to a mm251............hell marko just sell your shop to me and get a pm300 with a spool gun and you will have a complete welding shop in one box.....

btw im in citrus in april.........

Dawg
even a old dawg can learn new ticks !
Reply
Like

Markopolo
Advanced Member
Markopolo
Advanced Member
Joined: 30 Jul 2005, 13:47

27 Dec 2005, 02:08 #6

OK.....Clintonwelding......REMEMBER, I'm talking about two different machines, a Miller Thunderbolt, and a Lincoln Precisiontig 185.......The Thunderbolt is a "Buzz-Box".....where the Precisiontig is a "square wave machine".....but they are both capable of stick welding.

Paul......I hate to say this, but I think you may be right !......(Lincoln has got stick-welding down to a science) !

Brian....The Heliarc is already there, so it will get dirty whether I use it or not !

If I ever "upgrade" to a bigger MIG, I'm thinking a Lincoln Powermig 300 push-pull....BUT....I really don't need it. For heavy-duty work, I'll take my stick, and for the finer work, my little Hobart Handler 135 has proven itself....(and of course, I have the gas rig).....And thanks to you, I'm getting pretty good at Heliarc ! ;)

Marko.
"Any day above ground is a good one !"
Reply
Like

arcdawg
Advanced Member
arcdawg
Advanced Member
Joined: 09 Jul 2005, 15:19

27 Dec 2005, 16:56 #7

sounds good marko....


dawg
even a old dawg can learn new ticks !
Reply
Like