Forum rules
Welcome to Q&A! If you have questions that you want to ask, please shoot them right here.
Please only post questions here.

The topic title should clearly suggest the questions you are about to ask or already contain the question itself.
A bad topic title would be [i]PLEASE HELP!!! [/i], [i]IMPORTANT QUESTION! [/i], [i]ANSWER ME! [/i] or [i]QUESTIONS [/i] and the like. Topics like this will be closed.
A good topic title would be [i]Choosing between Maparam triple and Focalink Triple [/i] or [i]The differences between an Ocarina and a Bamboo Chopstick? [/i]

Happy asking!

STL and TNG Purple Clay

Tennyson
Transverse Ocarinist x 2
Transverse Ocarinist x 2
Joined: March 18th, 2016, 3:09 am

April 26th, 2018, 6:59 am #1

Hi! :)

I upload below some pictures of a STL Purple Clay Soprano C ocarina and a TNG Purple Clay Soprano C ocarina.

The STL Purple Clay series is produced by TNG.

However, the TNG model is quite different from the STL model (windway, shape, consistence, sound - to some extent -, color).

I was thinking they were the same.

My question is, is TNG producing a special 'line' of purple clay ocarinas for STL?

And, if yes, why? What is 'wrong' with the original TNG models?

At the level of sound, the two models are both ok, way 'sweeter' than other soprano ocarinas. However, they definitely 'play' differently.

A little bit paradoxically, the TNG model has the TNG stamp / 'brand' on it, while the STL model has the TNG stamp in Japanese (they are Japanese, not Chinese, characters, which is weird, since TNG is from Taiwan) on its 'back'. The 'Japanese' TNG stamp on the 'back' of the STL ocarina says, more or less, "House of the Clay Flute", and it is the same visible on the TNG website.

I was wondering about the differences of these two 'lines' of purple clay ocarinas produced by the same maker and if somebody knows the story / history behind them.

Moreover, at least at the moment, STL seems to sell its 'special' TNG purple clay 'line' only for the Soprano C, Soprano F, and Alto C models (I do not call them with the STL 'terminology'), while the Bass C model is a 'regular' TNG model, as well as the related double and triple purple clay ocarinas, STL Website.

However, I remember also an Alto G Purple Clay ocarina sold by STL, and it was like the 'special' ones (I own the 'regular' TNG model, and it is quite different).

Can somebody help in explaining this purple clay 'double series' produced by TNG and its / their characteristics?

Thank you very much! :)

Pictures
[+] Spoiler

[+] Spoiler

[+] Spoiler

[+] Spoiler

[+] Spoiler

[+] Spoiler

[+] Spoiler

[+] Spoiler

[+] Spoiler

[+] Spoiler
Last edited by Tennyson on April 26th, 2018, 7:05 am, edited 7 times in total.
Semper fidelis
Quote
Like
Share

Bryce
Quadruple Ocarinist
Quadruple Ocarinist
Joined: July 28th, 2012, 7:36 pm

April 29th, 2018, 2:11 am #2

The ones STL sells are the same models they've been selling for years. TNG used to sell the same model; however, they've changed and updated the line a couple times in the past couple years.
Quote
Like
Share

Tennyson
Transverse Ocarinist x 2
Transverse Ocarinist x 2
Joined: March 18th, 2016, 3:09 am

May 4th, 2018, 7:51 am #3


Thank you very much for your kind reply! :)

Unfortunately, I have seen it only today.

If I have well understood, the STL one is the 'standard' / 'original' model, while the TNG one is the 'updated' / 'newer' model, is it right?

Actually, the STL model is, at the 'conceptual' level, 'older' than the TNG one (I mean the models in my pictures)?

I am looking forward to hearing from you and thank you very much again! :)
Semper fidelis
Quote
Like
Share