Link: Copy link
O.K. Dr. Crump and Wordkeeper, this is not about musical instruments in a public worship setting. (Although I admit the lines between cross so easily)Wordkeeper: "Anyone who judges another person who worships with instrumental music is taking God off his throne sitting in His place and propagating an eleventh commandment 'Thou shall not worship with instrumental music.'"
There are more than just the Ten Commandments of the Old Testament. When Christ told us to observe all things whatsoever He commanded us (Matt. 28:20), He was referring to the commands of the Gospel and what He would later reveal to the apostolic writers: for example, baptism for remission of sins and salvation, repentance, confession that Jesus is Lord, the Lord's Supper, divorce only for adultery of the other spouse, a cappella music, etc. All of those, and more, are not part of the Ten Commandments, but commandments they are, nonetheless.
Wordkeeper: "...this issue [music] is personal preference and outside of any doctrinal boudaries."
Sorry, but since Eph. 5:19 and Col. 3:16 specify using only vocal music (a cappella), this goes beyond personal preference. Vocal music must be regarded as a command. After all, the apostle Paul stated that what he preached was revealed to him by Christ (Gal. 1:11-12). Everything that Paul wrote came to him from Christ. Only in rare instances did Paul insert personal opinions into his epistles, and when he did, he flagged them accordingly so that people would not mistake them as commands from Christ. An example is 1 Cor. 1:12, in which Paul gives a personal opinion about a disbelieving wife, and he flagged his words as opinion. Paul did not give a personal opinion about vocal music, because it is a command that he received from Christ.
It is a mistake to assume that because God hasn't specifically forbidden something by name, then it's OK to use it, especially when it pertains to doctrine and worship. Would we have God list every conceivable "Thou shalt" and "Thou shalt not" known to man? The list would be virtually endless. What God has written and specified in the New Testament should be sufficient unto itself. The silence of God is not permissive, and Christians have no authority to go beyond what is written in Scripture, regarding doctrine and worship. What does not conflict with doctrine, worship, or other biblical principles, Christians may implement. In the case of music, God through Paul has specified vocal music by name; to assume that instrumental music is also OK is to second-guess God, which is dangerous. Since we don't have that authority, it's far better to leave instruments alone. And no one is "judging" anybody. We are simply urging people not to allow their personal preferences to supercede what is specified in the New Testament.