((I think first day lynch is in no way beneficial to the townsfolk))
Solomir was the local store owner of the village. The day before had been very slow, with few customers and many whispered rumors. It was late afternoon by the time he discovered the reason for the slow business. In any case, Solomir had decided against voting to lynch someone, but paid close attention to the others around him.
Solomir heard the rumors early in the morning, and decided to close the shop down for the day. Why bother trying to sell things when people were too busy pointing fingers to remember to keep the good shopkeeper in business?
But what's this? The victim was not one of the big lynch mob from the day before. Instead he was merely a quiet bystander, a scholar tending to his own interests. Solomir instead thought back to the previous day and the people who had called for the lynching.
"There are two most suspiscious people here in this town. These people supported the lynching of somebody yesterday, because having less villagers to vote for a lynch is beneficial to their objective of killing us all.
"Dodd, you are a traveler and have only stayed here a week. Why is it that we've not had werewolf troubles until shortly after you arrived? Next you accused poor SRJJJB, stating he was an obvious suspect? 'How was he obvious?' I ask. You gave no real reason, yet expected us to believe your allegations. Also, you were the first to point at SJRB, but did not retract your statement after he admitted to being a common villager. Maybe you wanted him to die, regardless of his innocence?
"Order of Strife, you claim to be the only survivor of a recent werewolf hunt in Edam. How then, could you not be a werewolf yourself? If a town needs a majority vote to lynch the werewolf, then there should be another survivor beside yourself. Additionally, you seemeed keen on ensuring poor SRJJJB would hang, even AFTER he had declared his own innocence as a townsfolk. Maybe you wanted to ensure his death, so you could again be the 'sole survivor' of another werewolf hunt?
"I am no seer, and therefore cannot verify my beliefs. But maybe one among you is, and can help us to pin down the true killer. For now I point at Order of Strife as our suspected werewolf. Even if he were not, his death will lessen the confusion around the town."
Solomir looked around and noticed people had fallen asleep during his long speech. Hopefully the ones still awake had listened and would make the right decision. He hurried back to the store to find a bottle of water to ease his throat, parched from talking for way too long.
EDITED: to fix Sky's name (why'd you have to pick a name that people are bound to get wrong anyway?)