My SA Set up and turn: APPLES
Conventional Golf Set Up and turn: ORANGES
I think you were looking for me to have a more "Hoganesque", hands hanging, more bent over turn (as evidenced by your referring to the Utube Hogan clips.) Which would look more "pro" to your eyes. The key point is to turn around your spine, which is a "level shoulder turn". I do that with both set ups, my SA set up is just much more erect albeit a bit hunch backed.
These are posed static pics that mama was hesitant to let me take because of room, but you get the idea. End of denial?
I still don't like it.
Look at Scott: http://www.scigolf.com/scigolf/swing.htm
You appear to be rolling your lead shoulder as a takeaway,
almost an over the top backswing. Scott's takeaway seems
to be issuing out of his lead armpit.
But the level of your play speaks for itself and my comments
are just comments. Play on.