what do you guys think about this tintype?

what do you guys think about this tintype?

Joined: September 30th, 2008, 7:43 pm

April 27th, 2009, 4:54 am #1

just picked up this tintype and was looking for some opinions or guesses from experts. there isn't anything printed on the back identifying what state or town the photo is from. the image is very bold and the original paper frame is fully intact. really cool piece. what i was hoping to get some opinions on was whether or not you guys think these are perhaps organized league players. not quite professional but maybe some sort of traveling team? the equipment they have, from what i can see, looks to be of high quality. the bat looks professionally made and not home fashioned, and the ball the other gentlemen is holding appears to be of quality too. i was thinking maybe they're on opposing teams? they kind of looks like uniforms to me and not just clothes. to me the men look like ball players and not the village butcher or doctor. what do you guys think? any date approximations? my guess is early 1870s.

[/IMG]
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: October 19th, 2004, 12:02 am

April 27th, 2009, 10:36 am #2

It's a very nice image, well posed with equipment showing and spiffy uniforms, but the chance of identifying the players without any corroborating information is slim and none. Even trying to guess what level they are is almost impossible. Enjoy it as an exceptional early baseball image.
Last edited by barrysloate on April 27th, 2009, 10:38 am, edited 1 time in total.
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: April 6th, 2007, 3:03 pm

April 27th, 2009, 12:42 pm #3

just picked up this tintype and was looking for some opinions or guesses from experts. there isn't anything printed on the back identifying what state or town the photo is from. the image is very bold and the original paper frame is fully intact. really cool piece. what i was hoping to get some opinions on was whether or not you guys think these are perhaps organized league players. not quite professional but maybe some sort of traveling team? the equipment they have, from what i can see, looks to be of high quality. the bat looks professionally made and not home fashioned, and the ball the other gentlemen is holding appears to be of quality too. i was thinking maybe they're on opposing teams? they kind of looks like uniforms to me and not just clothes. to me the men look like ball players and not the village butcher or doctor. what do you guys think? any date approximations? my guess is early 1870s.

[/IMG]
1870s, but very hard as Barry stated to id the players without info on shirts.

nice clear photo

Jimmy
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: November 22nd, 2008, 9:29 pm

April 27th, 2009, 5:52 pm #4

just picked up this tintype and was looking for some opinions or guesses from experts. there isn't anything printed on the back identifying what state or town the photo is from. the image is very bold and the original paper frame is fully intact. really cool piece. what i was hoping to get some opinions on was whether or not you guys think these are perhaps organized league players. not quite professional but maybe some sort of traveling team? the equipment they have, from what i can see, looks to be of high quality. the bat looks professionally made and not home fashioned, and the ball the other gentlemen is holding appears to be of quality too. i was thinking maybe they're on opposing teams? they kind of looks like uniforms to me and not just clothes. to me the men look like ball players and not the village butcher or doctor. what do you guys think? any date approximations? my guess is early 1870s.

[/IMG]
A refreshing thing about tintypes is the names and team are rarely ever known, so you judge and valuate them on things other than star power.
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: September 30th, 2008, 7:43 pm

April 27th, 2009, 6:07 pm #5

just picked up this tintype and was looking for some opinions or guesses from experts. there isn't anything printed on the back identifying what state or town the photo is from. the image is very bold and the original paper frame is fully intact. really cool piece. what i was hoping to get some opinions on was whether or not you guys think these are perhaps organized league players. not quite professional but maybe some sort of traveling team? the equipment they have, from what i can see, looks to be of high quality. the bat looks professionally made and not home fashioned, and the ball the other gentlemen is holding appears to be of quality too. i was thinking maybe they're on opposing teams? they kind of looks like uniforms to me and not just clothes. to me the men look like ball players and not the village butcher or doctor. what do you guys think? any date approximations? my guess is early 1870s.

[/IMG]
i definitely don't expect to ID the players. but what do you guys think about the equipment and uniforms? i'm just looking for guesses so feel free to speculate. do the clothes they're wearing look like uniforms to you? or just some fancy get ups? it looks like they're both wearing those customary belts that the early teams like the Excelsiors and the like used to wear. maybe they're part of fireman teams?
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: October 19th, 2004, 12:02 am

April 27th, 2009, 6:17 pm #6

just picked up this tintype and was looking for some opinions or guesses from experts. there isn't anything printed on the back identifying what state or town the photo is from. the image is very bold and the original paper frame is fully intact. really cool piece. what i was hoping to get some opinions on was whether or not you guys think these are perhaps organized league players. not quite professional but maybe some sort of traveling team? the equipment they have, from what i can see, looks to be of high quality. the bat looks professionally made and not home fashioned, and the ball the other gentlemen is holding appears to be of quality too. i was thinking maybe they're on opposing teams? they kind of looks like uniforms to me and not just clothes. to me the men look like ball players and not the village butcher or doctor. what do you guys think? any date approximations? my guess is early 1870s.

[/IMG]
Fireman and baseball uniforms can be hard to differentiate as so many fire companies fielded baseball teams. The bat of course clinches it as baseball. The uniforms are ornate but those ties are pretty common in the 1870's. I always wondered if they actually played wearing those things.

Just wanted to add that ballplayers likely dressed up a bit for photographs. Going to a studio and having your picture taken was kind of a big thing back then (and still can be today).
Last edited by barrysloate on April 27th, 2009, 6:20 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: November 22nd, 2008, 9:29 pm

April 27th, 2009, 6:26 pm #7

just picked up this tintype and was looking for some opinions or guesses from experts. there isn't anything printed on the back identifying what state or town the photo is from. the image is very bold and the original paper frame is fully intact. really cool piece. what i was hoping to get some opinions on was whether or not you guys think these are perhaps organized league players. not quite professional but maybe some sort of traveling team? the equipment they have, from what i can see, looks to be of high quality. the bat looks professionally made and not home fashioned, and the ball the other gentlemen is holding appears to be of quality too. i was thinking maybe they're on opposing teams? they kind of looks like uniforms to me and not just clothes. to me the men look like ball players and not the village butcher or doctor. what do you guys think? any date approximations? my guess is early 1870s.

[/IMG]
Won't speculate on teams, but it's a nice example as it's 1870s and shows bat and ball.
Last edited by dereb12 on April 27th, 2009, 6:30 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: September 30th, 2008, 7:43 pm

April 27th, 2009, 6:46 pm #8

just picked up this tintype and was looking for some opinions or guesses from experts. there isn't anything printed on the back identifying what state or town the photo is from. the image is very bold and the original paper frame is fully intact. really cool piece. what i was hoping to get some opinions on was whether or not you guys think these are perhaps organized league players. not quite professional but maybe some sort of traveling team? the equipment they have, from what i can see, looks to be of high quality. the bat looks professionally made and not home fashioned, and the ball the other gentlemen is holding appears to be of quality too. i was thinking maybe they're on opposing teams? they kind of looks like uniforms to me and not just clothes. to me the men look like ball players and not the village butcher or doctor. what do you guys think? any date approximations? my guess is early 1870s.

[/IMG]
thanks for the input guys. my favorite aspect of the tintype is that the original frame is fully intact. makes for a very nice presentation.
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: November 22nd, 2008, 9:29 pm

April 27th, 2009, 7:11 pm #9

just picked up this tintype and was looking for some opinions or guesses from experts. there isn't anything printed on the back identifying what state or town the photo is from. the image is very bold and the original paper frame is fully intact. really cool piece. what i was hoping to get some opinions on was whether or not you guys think these are perhaps organized league players. not quite professional but maybe some sort of traveling team? the equipment they have, from what i can see, looks to be of high quality. the bat looks professionally made and not home fashioned, and the ball the other gentlemen is holding appears to be of quality too. i was thinking maybe they're on opposing teams? they kind of looks like uniforms to me and not just clothes. to me the men look like ball players and not the village butcher or doctor. what do you guys think? any date approximations? my guess is early 1870s.

[/IMG]
I agree that the paper holder is nice, plus uncommon for baseball tintypes. The holder was used to give the image a frame and make the tintype resemble a CDV, and you could refer to yours as a CDV tintype if you wish.
Last edited by dereb12 on April 27th, 2009, 7:15 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Quote
Like
Share