Which is Best?

Joined: 1:53 PM - Mar 11, 2004

9:57 PM - Nov 02, 2004 #1

Out of all the Myst novels (so far three), which is your favorite?

Total votes: 8
3(38%)
4(50%)
1(13%)

I think that the Book of Ti'ana is the best of them all... thats why i read it ten times
This is my signature. You were expecting maybe Saavedro?
The Kamishima Journals | KDNI Radio
Quote
Like
Share

Marina
Colonel
Marina
Colonel
Joined: 1:07 PM - Jan 18, 2005

5:11 PM - Jul 10, 2005 #2

Ti'ana is my fav. Most helpful of the three as far as learning about the D'ni goes.
I'll put in a good word for ya!
http://guildofslayers.jconserv.net
Quote
Like
Share

cfischer83
General
Joined: 6:31 AM - Feb 16, 2004

3:53 AM - Jul 11, 2005 #3

Book of Atrus... filled in so many holes for Myst and Riven. Although BoT did fill in a lot about the D'ni civilization, I still liked the 'surprise' in BoA.

Poor BoD never does well in these polls! lol
:smoking:

Those who forget the pasta...... are condemned to reheat it....
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: 1:53 PM - Mar 11, 2004

1:09 PM - Jul 11, 2005 #4

hmm... it didn't quite fit with the rest of the series... combination of no explanation of where Averone came from (obviously he wrote it, but us pseudo-intellectual types want proof) and the very end, with a sort of journal entry by Catherine... makes sense, but then BoA should have started with one. End of BoD seemed to be more continuing an entry, so BoA would start, maybe BoT would continue it, and it would end in BoD... now with Book of Marrim, everything's shot, but would have made BoD a bit better...

lol, long post, and I remember reading the books last to first, BoD, BoT, then BoA 6 months later
This is my signature. You were expecting maybe Saavedro?
The Kamishima Journals | KDNI Radio
Quote
Like
Share

cfischer83
General
Joined: 6:31 AM - Feb 16, 2004

6:32 AM - Jul 14, 2005 #5

lol, yeah long post, never seen more than one sentence per post out of ya. ;)
:smoking:

Those who forget the pasta...... are condemned to reheat it....
Quote
Like
Share

Marina
Colonel
Marina
Colonel
Joined: 1:07 PM - Jan 18, 2005

3:47 PM - Jul 14, 2005 #6

what, did you think you were emailing?
I'll put in a good word for ya!
http://guildofslayers.jconserv.net
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: 1:53 PM - Mar 11, 2004

3:48 PM - Jul 14, 2005 #7

:D the power of Krispy Kremes....
This is my signature. You were expecting maybe Saavedro?
The Kamishima Journals | KDNI Radio
Quote
Like
Share

Scotty1701
Cadet
Joined: 10:59 PM - Jul 29, 2005

11:08 PM - Jul 29, 2005 #8

Ti'ana........Hands down the best of the three. A truly epic novel. I even sparked a tear at the end! :honestly:
Quote
Like
Share

CK9
General
CK9
General
Joined: 6:07 PM - Feb 21, 2004

9:20 AM - Jul 30, 2005 #9

the ultimate sacrifice
Life and Death meet as one
"Sorrow is just a step on the path to bliss"
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: 1:53 PM - Mar 11, 2004

1:47 AM - Jul 31, 2005 #10

loaned m copy to a friend sometime 3rd quarter of school.... haven't gotten it back yet, and I'm running out of reading material...
This is my signature. You were expecting maybe Saavedro?
The Kamishima Journals | KDNI Radio
Quote
Like
Share

cfischer83
General
Joined: 6:31 AM - Feb 16, 2004

6:43 AM - Aug 04, 2005 #11

I lent my paperback BoA to someone back in WA and never got it back :|
:smoking:

Those who forget the pasta...... are condemned to reheat it....
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: 1:53 PM - Mar 11, 2004

11:20 PM - Aug 06, 2005 #12

hee hee oops

its ok, i'll see him in a few weeks anyway, with school starting again and all :annoyed:
This is my signature. You were expecting maybe Saavedro?
The Kamishima Journals | KDNI Radio
Quote
Like
Share

CK9
General
CK9
General
Joined: 6:07 PM - Feb 21, 2004

6:16 PM - Aug 07, 2005 #13

CF, contact the person and hav them mail it. Dice, if they act dumb, show no mercy!
Life and Death meet as one
"Sorrow is just a step on the path to bliss"
Quote
Like
Share

Joined: 1:53 PM - Mar 11, 2004

2:22 PM - Aug 10, 2005 #14

yes sir :annoyed:
This is my signature. You were expecting maybe Saavedro?
The Kamishima Journals | KDNI Radio
Quote
Like
Share

hailahh
Cadet
Joined: 2:13 PM - Jul 08, 2005

2:24 AM - Aug 21, 2005 #15

Book of Atrus is the only one that really impressed me and got to me emotionally. I began to have respect for the Millers in a new dimension - that there was a depth to their world and worldview I hadn't realized before.
Quote
Like
Share

cfischer83
General
Joined: 6:31 AM - Feb 16, 2004

7:39 AM - Aug 21, 2005 #16

Thank you!!!! Someone who sees what I saw... ;)
:smoking:

Those who forget the pasta...... are condemned to reheat it....
Quote
Like
Share