SYW and a look at Might and Reason

For all those 18th century delights.
Jeremy Sutcliffe
Emperor of the table
Joined: 17 Feb 2009, 21:57

03 Mar 2011, 09:58 #1

This was my second game with Sam Mustafa's "Might and Reason" rules. I tried them first about 18 months ago but something didn't quite click. However there is something about the command and control system which intrigues me so I thought another look was in order.
How to explain it?
The CinC rolls each turn for a number of "Command Dice" (the better the CinC the more he can try for) which he can then use to improve the chances of his choice of Sub Commander activating units successfully.
A game "turn" however consists of up to four "pulses" depending each pulse on a d4 result so budgeting the extra extra dice is a challenge.
Another twist in the rules is that the quality of a sub general is determined after the units have been allocated to him. Mustafa justifies this by saying 18thC CinCs had to cope with monarchs' favourites in subordinate command roles.
This was to prove my undoing for the second time playing M&R. Despite having an inspired Prussian general with the potential for lots of extra dice and a sub commander generating table geared to give me quality, I rolled a batch of poor quality subordinates. Frederick what were you thinking of?
Otherwise the game systems are relatively simple and straight forward. It uses notional two stand units and although it recommends on table strength counters I made up Principles of War type roster shhets to mark quality deterioration.
With the arrival of Black Powder, I'm not sure I'll pursue M&R much further although there are lots of scenarios on line.
Game pictures
Old Glory 15s Prussians (and a very old Minifig gun - from the days of the Minifig 15mm strips) wait to advance. [And wait and wait - poor dice throwing]
Image
Prussian Cavalry advance on the flank. (Essex figures in the foreground, the others a mix of Lancashire Games and some Irregular)
Image
And on the French side of the table.... (White uniformed figures OGs. The lads in blue old Minifigs, the gun Essex)
Image
The cavalry wings collide. The same sort of figure mix for the French
Image
Prussian units push forward. Another mix of figures. My SYW set up has developed over the years and is an eclectic mix of figures.
Image

Image
Reply

nevermore
Armchair General
Joined: 10 Feb 2011, 17:04

07 Mar 2011, 07:40 #2

excellent,love the flags they look the biz
Reply

Jeremy Sutcliffe
Emperor of the table
Joined: 17 Feb 2009, 21:57

07 Mar 2011, 08:40 #3

QUOTE (nevermore @ March 07, 2011 07:40 am)
excellent,love the flags they look the biz

Agreed.
With the old Minifig units which had a tiny metal one I persuaded Alan Lumley of Lancashire Games to supply me with spare standard bearers so I could use the larger paper ones. (And thanks to warflag of course)
Reply