Seedlings-To Pinch or Not to Pinch?

Seedlings-To Pinch or Not to Pinch?

Joined: March 6th, 2008, 2:20 am

April 20th, 2017, 3:26 am #1

What seedlings do you or don't you pinch and when? Just curious & also looking for a few answers.

My Eccremocarpus scaber seedlings have a lot of space between the sets if leaves. Since this is a vine, I assume no pinch?

How bout Zinnias or Cosmos? The main stem is very tall & some are starting to get their true leaves & they are flopping even though the light is directly over them.

How bout greggii/microphylla type Salvias? They grow similar to the Eccremo seedlings.

I haven't pinched my tomatoes or peppers in the past but pinch out the Y's after they are already big & in ground for a bit. Never had a problem with their growth.

Also don't pinch Scarlet Runner beans or Ipomoea luteola which have done fine in the past. (I assume no pinch for vines?)

These are the only seedlings I can think of that would be approaching this stage.

Joni
Elwood, IL
Zone 5
Reply
Like
Share

Joined: May 21st, 2013, 12:09 am

April 20th, 2017, 3:23 pm #2

I never tried to pinch vines and I don't pinch Zinnias or Cosmos although I suppose you could. Salvia like greggii/microphylla are another matter, those usually get pinched. I do my best when it comes to Zinnias, Cosmos, Tomatoes and annual vines to time their starting so that they don't get too large ahead of time. It is not like there is any advantage to larger older plants. My Zinnia, annual vines etc. are just now getting true leaves and ready for transplant into individual cells. In a couple of weeks they will be in the ground I hope.
Reply
Like
Share

Joined: May 18th, 2013, 9:33 pm

April 21st, 2017, 2:38 am #3

What seedlings do you or don't you pinch and when? Just curious & also looking for a few answers.

My Eccremocarpus scaber seedlings have a lot of space between the sets if leaves. Since this is a vine, I assume no pinch?

How bout Zinnias or Cosmos? The main stem is very tall & some are starting to get their true leaves & they are flopping even though the light is directly over them.

How bout greggii/microphylla type Salvias? They grow similar to the Eccremo seedlings.

I haven't pinched my tomatoes or peppers in the past but pinch out the Y's after they are already big & in ground for a bit. Never had a problem with their growth.

Also don't pinch Scarlet Runner beans or Ipomoea luteola which have done fine in the past. (I assume no pinch for vines?)

These are the only seedlings I can think of that would be approaching this stage.

Joni
Elwood, IL
Zone 5
Depends on the type of plant , certain salvias, cupheas get pinched once they get going good, you know when that will be.
Steve W.
Martinsville IN.
Zone 6
Reply
Like
Share

Joined: March 5th, 2006, 2:03 am

April 21st, 2017, 12:33 pm #4

What seedlings do you or don't you pinch and when? Just curious & also looking for a few answers.

My Eccremocarpus scaber seedlings have a lot of space between the sets if leaves. Since this is a vine, I assume no pinch?

How bout Zinnias or Cosmos? The main stem is very tall & some are starting to get their true leaves & they are flopping even though the light is directly over them.

How bout greggii/microphylla type Salvias? They grow similar to the Eccremo seedlings.

I haven't pinched my tomatoes or peppers in the past but pinch out the Y's after they are already big & in ground for a bit. Never had a problem with their growth.

Also don't pinch Scarlet Runner beans or Ipomoea luteola which have done fine in the past. (I assume no pinch for vines?)

These are the only seedlings I can think of that would be approaching this stage.

Joni
Elwood, IL
Zone 5
Are the seedlings well rooted? If so, you can pretty much pinch any of them to get a desired shape. I'm sure you know that pruning any green leaves tends to slow down the growth of roots and therefore the growth of the plant.

Central Florida 9B
Reply
Like
Share

Joined: January 10th, 2016, 12:32 am

April 25th, 2017, 12:36 am #5

What seedlings do you or don't you pinch and when? Just curious & also looking for a few answers.

My Eccremocarpus scaber seedlings have a lot of space between the sets if leaves. Since this is a vine, I assume no pinch?

How bout Zinnias or Cosmos? The main stem is very tall & some are starting to get their true leaves & they are flopping even though the light is directly over them.

How bout greggii/microphylla type Salvias? They grow similar to the Eccremo seedlings.

I haven't pinched my tomatoes or peppers in the past but pinch out the Y's after they are already big & in ground for a bit. Never had a problem with their growth.

Also don't pinch Scarlet Runner beans or Ipomoea luteola which have done fine in the past. (I assume no pinch for vines?)

These are the only seedlings I can think of that would be approaching this stage.

Joni
Elwood, IL
Zone 5
Great question!!! What about nasturtiums???? I have never grown them before...I have them in pots with my Canna lilly know what to do with them...
Reply
Like
Share

Joined: May 21st, 2013, 12:09 am

April 25th, 2017, 12:53 pm #6

What seedlings do you or don't you pinch and when? Just curious & also looking for a few answers.

My Eccremocarpus scaber seedlings have a lot of space between the sets if leaves. Since this is a vine, I assume no pinch?

How bout Zinnias or Cosmos? The main stem is very tall & some are starting to get their true leaves & they are flopping even though the light is directly over them.

How bout greggii/microphylla type Salvias? They grow similar to the Eccremo seedlings.

I haven't pinched my tomatoes or peppers in the past but pinch out the Y's after they are already big & in ground for a bit. Never had a problem with their growth.

Also don't pinch Scarlet Runner beans or Ipomoea luteola which have done fine in the past. (I assume no pinch for vines?)

These are the only seedlings I can think of that would be approaching this stage.

Joni
Elwood, IL
Zone 5
It might not be a good idea to pinch nasturtiums or any other annual vine for that matter. In fact there is not general rule to go by with annuals - some yes, some no. On bushy annuals like zinnia and cosmos there could be some point to pinching them but only if they have gotten tall. Doing it too early could damage the growth of the plant be removing too many leaves. The truth is they will branch anyway whether pinched or not.

Pinching tomatoes and peppers, never tried that. No matter what I do the tomatoes will be 6 plus feet tall by the end of July and who knows with the peppers? There are so many pepper diseases these days that I never know what will happen with them. At home we've gone to full quarantine, resolved to only plant the ones we have started and never bring in a plant from a local nursery. I searched the internet trying to find a pepper resistant to the 9 kinds of leaf spot and ended up having to spend $22.00 for a single packet of seeds, a bell called Turnpike. The only other pepper that appears to be surefire against leaf spot is Serrano. It is a very ornamental hot pepper and gets almost 5 feet tall. It packs a bit of a punch which I don't mind and it is reliable.
Reply
Like
Share

Joined: March 6th, 2008, 2:20 am

April 26th, 2017, 11:18 pm #7

What seedlings do you or don't you pinch and when? Just curious & also looking for a few answers.

My Eccremocarpus scaber seedlings have a lot of space between the sets if leaves. Since this is a vine, I assume no pinch?

How bout Zinnias or Cosmos? The main stem is very tall & some are starting to get their true leaves & they are flopping even though the light is directly over them.

How bout greggii/microphylla type Salvias? They grow similar to the Eccremo seedlings.

I haven't pinched my tomatoes or peppers in the past but pinch out the Y's after they are already big & in ground for a bit. Never had a problem with their growth.

Also don't pinch Scarlet Runner beans or Ipomoea luteola which have done fine in the past. (I assume no pinch for vines?)

These are the only seedlings I can think of that would be approaching this stage.

Joni
Elwood, IL
Zone 5
Thanks for the replies. None are rooted well enough yet then. I didn't know pinching retarded root growth so I sure wouldn't want to set anything back at this stage. Once these colder nights go away & I can get stuff potted up & outside into some heat, they will probably straighten up. I wouldn't pinch my vines but the Eccremocarpus seedlings have a lot of space between each set of leaves. Hopefully, they will thicken up when moved out into more sun & heat as well.

As for my Nasturtiums, I didn't start the "vine types" but in the past, I've bought them in pots where they grew mounded & that is how they are growing now. They look very good. Will need to post a pix.

Ward,
I have never had problems with any Peppers, grown from see or bought (other than being very slow from seed). Never have anything bother them except an occasional much of a leaf from time to time. That is weird. Did you ever grow 'Melrose'? I hate anything but black pepper (ha!) but grow for the family but that is the only one I will eat. It's a sweet Italian frying pepper but tastes like a very mild sweet bell & I eat them raw on salads. Gave my overflow to a neighbor who grilled them & said they were the best pepper he ever ate. Good on RB sammies.

Joni
Elwood, IL
Zone 5
Reply
Like
Share


Confirmation of reply: