Official Animation Contest #8 Results

Unryze
Chieftan
Unryze
Chieftan
Joined: April 11th, 2013, 11:08 am

September 10th, 2017, 3:19 pm #1


1st Place
2nd Place
3rd Place
ChelyzMarx
- 1st place Forum Medal
- 5000 Gold
MagaRa
- 2nd place Forum Medal
- 2000 Gold
Guide_to_Jesus
- 3d place Forum Medal
- 1000 Gold
- 200 Gold for every Participant that sent his entry in time.

ChelyzMarx
[Vegeta SS4]
Smooth Flow: [25/25]
- Nothing can be said, just brilliant!
Effects/Extras: [9/10]
- Very creative dissipate, and alternative set of animations! Sadly -1 point for not having any effects, I wish you had it!
Choreography: [6/7]
- Sadly, some of the punches felt really weak, however they looked very clean, so only 1 point deducted.
Clean Bones: [5/5]
- Nothing to add, clean!
Creativity: [10/10]
- All animations suit the hero and were done with a lot of care and dedication, again, I feel defeated.
Usefulness: [10/10]
- A rare occasion, when ALL of the animations, can't be just used, they SHOULD be used, ouch!
Functionality: [8/8]
- If I could add more points, I would, sadly I can't. Great job!
Overall Score: [73/75]
- To tell the truth, I was blown by your work, I even feel guilty for not giving full points. Thank you very much for such an amazing submission!
MagaRa
[OxKing]
Smooth Flow: [25/25]
- Despite the animations being pretty simple, they were very smooth and soft.
Effects/Extras: [0/10]
- Sadly, no effects are present on the model, so nothing to give here.
Choreography: [6/7]
- If the animations would suit Ox King more, it would have been a 7, however some animations feel a bit weak for such a brute.
Clean Bones: [5/5]
- No useless bones and attachments are pretty clean!
Creativity: [6/10]
- Sadly, I believe that you could have done much more with him, thus I can't give more than 5, as most animations are just basic.
Usefulness: [10/10]
- Animations fit to the name so they can be used.
Functionality: [8/8]
- All of the animations can be used, great job!
Overall Score: [60/75]
- You did a good job on this model, but hopefully you will do better next time!
Smooth Flow: [23/25]
- Animations are really good, but the walk animation threw me off, sadly, couldn't give max points.
Effects/Extras: [4/10]
- Additional mesh movements are great, thus some extra points achieved!
Choreography: [5/7]
- Everything is good, but dissipate and walk.
Clean Bones: [5/5]
- No useless bones and attachments are pretty clean!
Creativity: [8/10]
- Sadly, yet again affected by dissipate and walk.
Usefulness: [10/10]
- Animations fit to the name so they can be used.
Functionality: [8/8]
- All of the animations can be used, great job!
Overall Score: [63/75]
- I liked what you did on this model, I suppose you liked animating this one much more than OxKing
[/color]
Total Score: 60 + 63 = 123 / 2 = 61.5 + 8.5 Extra points for additional model = [70]!

Guide_to_Jesus
[Black Panther]

Smooth Flow: [22/25]
- Point deduction for a bit unbalanced walk animation and a bit static Attack 3 animations.
Effects/Extras: [8/10]
- Very interesting concept of dissipate, well done! And fire effect usage, again, well done!
Choreography: [5/7]
- Sadly, due to the animations mentioned above, I couldn't give full points.
Clean Bones: [5/5]
- Nothing to add, clean!
Creativity: [8/10]
- Creativity is certainly there, but due to some animations lacking it, I had to deduct points.
Usefulness: [10/10]
- Animations fit to the name so they can be used.
Functionality: [8/8]
- All of the animations can be used, great job!
Overall Score: [66/75]
- Very good submission with, however it could be better, make your animations with a bit more physics, and it will be golden!
Dennis Hermann
[Kyoraku Shunsui]
Smooth Flow: [20/25]
- Death animation is way too fast, dissipate is alright, but again, too fast.
- Spell Channel has no movement.
- Walk is just not good at all, I would remove it and keep walk fast instead.

Effects/Extras: [0/10]
- Nothing.
Choreography: [4/7]
- Due to some animations being way too "boring" this score maxed out at 4.
Clean Bones: [4/5]
- Mark was tuned down, due to model complexity and how bones can never really be clean on it, sorry!
Creativity: [7/10]
- Creativity is certainly there, but again, point deduction for some animations that ruin perspective of them.
Usefulness: [10/10]
- Animations fit to the name so they can be used.
Functionality: [8/8]
- All of the animations can be used, great job!
Overall Score: [53/75]
- The concept was very good, but I could feel a bit of laziness, which is never a good thing for an animator.
Marek
[MULE]
Smooth Flow: [20/25]
- Attack and Attack 2 are not good, and lack smoothness.
- Dissipate is just hiding. Sadly, points were deducted because of this.

Effects/Extras: [4/10]
- Well done with using dust effects, fire and a mineral. Also additional skins!
Choreography: [2/7]
- Sadly, some animations are repeated, thus I could not give points for them, as for the rest it is clean.
Clean Bones: [5/5]
- Nothing to add, clean!
Creativity: [4/10]
- Creativity is certainly there, but a lot of animations were repeated and some did not have much of a movement.
Usefulness: [6/10]
- Animations fit, but yet again, some can be just removed, as they are copies.
Functionality: [8/8]
- All of the animations can be used, great job!
Overall Score: [49/75]
- I couldn't rate this any higher, due to a lot of reasons, however it was good!
[/size][/b][/color]
Norenne
[Norenne]
Smooth Flow: [5/25]
- Animations are too "static" and "jump" too much from frame to frame.
Effects/Extras: [2/10]
- Utilising hide/show mesh.
Choreography: [2/7]
- Even though the concept seems cool, the realisation is sadly below average.
Clean Bones: [3/5]
- Some bones could have been removed, overall - ok.
Creativity: [8/10]
- Creativity is certainly there, but sadly it does not look good, but hey, we are not judging it here.
Usefulness: [5/10]
- Animations fit to the name so they can be used. However, I cannot give full points, due to how they work.
Functionality: [8/8]
- All of the animations can be used, not going to deduce anything here.
Overall Score: [33/75]
- To tell the truth I wanted to give it a 0, as this model was used BEFORE the competition, but I hoped it would improve.
Sadly I was wrong, the model did not improve much, apart from fixing the bone rotation issues.
Last edited by Unryze on September 13th, 2017, 10:47 am, edited 9 times in total.
My Map Topic:http://chaosrealm.info/topic/10567032/
Official Map Site::http://vendew.info
Skype: Unryze
Garena: Unryze
Anime Character Fight and BvO Another Map Maker
Like
Share

Norenne
Chieftan
Norenne
Chieftan
Joined: May 3rd, 2016, 2:38 pm

September 10th, 2017, 3:34 pm #2

Heh, maybe it's not my thing.
The result did took long, so I don't mind.
Congrats whatever...
Like
Share

Unryze
Chieftan
Unryze
Chieftan
Joined: April 11th, 2013, 11:08 am

September 10th, 2017, 3:40 pm #3

Norenne wrote:Heh, maybe it's not my thing.
The result did took long, so I don't mind.
Congrats whatever...
Well, there is no need for taking contest so serious, not to mention, I was as fair as I could, and you kinda did cheat. And "the result did take long, so I don't mind" is a very rude thing to say you know? As it can be translated into "I no longer care", which is plain and simple childish.

Not to mention, you had additional time to fix what you did...

Anyways, hopefully you will learn from those that scored higher, ask them for advice, don't be shy ;)
My Map Topic:http://chaosrealm.info/topic/10567032/
Official Map Site::http://vendew.info
Skype: Unryze
Garena: Unryze
Anime Character Fight and BvO Another Map Maker
Like
Share

Norenne
Chieftan
Norenne
Chieftan
Joined: May 3rd, 2016, 2:38 pm

September 10th, 2017, 4:11 pm #4

I'd better luck next time if it happens again.
Yeah I'm abit rude but only to a sort of extent.
I happen to be scarred for life but I still care a bit.
Well, I win some, lose some.
Like
Share

MagaRa
Blade Master
MagaRa
Blade Master
Joined: July 18th, 2013, 2:34 pm

September 10th, 2017, 4:39 pm #5

Congratz to the amazing ChelyzMarx!

With all the great names here I didn't expect to rank that high. Congratulations to all participants and let's do this again sometime.
These contests should be fun and everyone who likes animating should participate(level of skill is less important).

Can we check out these models/animations?

P.S.
For death and dissipate animations for Venom I had an idea to make him turn into a human while symbiote retreats, but sadly I couldn't find model for Eddie Brock(carrier of Venom symbiote), so I just rushed with those animations.
Last edited by MagaRa on September 10th, 2017, 4:58 pm, edited 2 times in total.
Like
Share

Dennis Herrmann
Chaos Infernal
Dennis Herrmann
Chaos Infernal
Joined: April 25th, 2013, 6:29 am

September 10th, 2017, 5:32 pm #6

well next time i should let me some more time =)
I got wonderfull ideas, but not the time 2 make it xD
Watch at my brother his youtube channel =)

PhenomLP
Youtube Channel Phenomlp

Wip MY WIP

Like
Share

Unryze
Chieftan
Unryze
Chieftan
Joined: April 11th, 2013, 11:08 am

September 10th, 2017, 8:27 pm #7

I will add the models for download in a bit, hopefully you like the new layout I did for the contest results~
My Map Topic:http://chaosrealm.info/topic/10567032/
Official Map Site::http://vendew.info
Skype: Unryze
Garena: Unryze
Anime Character Fight and BvO Another Map Maker
Like
Share

PrinceYaser
Spirit Walker
PrinceYaser
Spirit Walker
Joined: July 11th, 2017, 11:19 am

September 11th, 2017, 5:42 am #8

Congratz guys!

General, how about other contest(I mean except animation)?
I hope you'll hold another contest that others could join, ha?
Last edited by PrinceYaser on September 11th, 2017, 5:45 am, edited 1 time in total.
Like
Share

ZanmaruRen
Blade Master
ZanmaruRen
Blade Master
Joined: April 3rd, 2012, 3:48 am

September 11th, 2017, 7:42 am #9

Congrats to the winner! And thank you for all the participants for the time and effort spent for this contest! Looking forward for the next contest! em_uhu!
Can't wait to watch all your model animations em_amazed

And love for the scoring layout! Good job, Tailer Unryze ><', classy! em_huh
Last edited by Unryze on September 11th, 2017, 7:55 am, edited 3 times in total.
If you wonder what I'm doin, click here
Interested in learning how to animate? Click here
Like
Share

TheUndertaker
Chieftan
Joined: January 5th, 2015, 6:37 am

September 11th, 2017, 7:52 am #10

Congrats ChelyzMarx and all of the participants! em_coolGuy
Like
Share